DOE PAGES title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information
  1. The solubility of ErPO4 and Er speciation in hydrothermal fluids at varying pH and salinity between 350 and 450 °C

    The rare earth elements (REE) are important for the green-energy transition and can be incorporated into the REE phosphates, such as xenotime-(Y), which also hosts heavy REE (Tb– Lu). Xenotime-(Y) is a common accessory mineral in metamorphic rocks and a range of mineral deposits where it controls the mobility of heavy REE, however, the impact of high temperature aqueous fluids on the behavior of heavy REE is largely unknown. Thermodynamic modeling can be utilized as a tool to predict the mobility of REE in hydrothermal aqueous fluids, but must be supported by accurate experimental data. Here, we measured the solubilitymore » of endmember synthetic xenotime-structured ErPO4 in NaCl-HCl-NaOH-bearing aqueous solutions at 350 °C and water vapor saturation pressure, at 400 and at 450 °C and 500 bar using batch-type Inconel reactors. Erbium speciation was investigated as a function of pH from 2.8 to 8, where Er chloride species are predominant at acidic conditions (pH <3) and Er hydroxyl complexes are predominant at near- neutral to alkaline conditions (pH >3). At pH 7–9, the measured ErPO4 solubility (-9.8 to -7.5 log mEr) is up to 2.5 orders of magnitude lower than thermodynamic predictions (-9.4 to -6.7 log mEr) using existing thermodynamic databases. At pH 2–3, the predicted ErPO4 solubility is ~0.5 orders of magnitude higher at 350 °C and ~1 order of magnitude lower at 450 °C compared to experimentally measured Er concentrations. The thermodynamic properties of aqueous Er species were therefore revised in this study. The partial molal Gibbs energy of formation (ΔfG0T,P) for aqueous Er hydroxyl and chloride species are optimized using GEMSFITS and the logarithmic formation constants (logβn(Cl,OH)) were derived at each experimental temperature and pressure. The updated thermodynamic properties for Er hydroxyl species (Er(OH)+2, Er(OH)2+, and Er(OH)30) show that their stability shifts to more acidic conditions at and below 400 °C. The Er chloride species (ErCl+2 and ErCl2+) show increased stability compared to Er hydroxyl species at temperatures of 450 °C and 0.01 mol/kg NaCl. The updated thermodynamic properties are implemented into the GEM-Selektor modeling package to investigate the mobility of Er in saline hydrothermal fluids in equilibrium with alkaline rocks. Importantly, the updated properties for Er hydroxyl species result in low Er solubility at rock equilibrated pH conditions due to an expanded hydroxyl predominance zone, but lower aqueous complex stability overall, whereas previous models suggest greater stability for aqueous Er species. Furthermore, ErPO4 solubility increases with decreasing temperature due to the deprotonation of HCl, which increases the acidity of hydrothermal fluids and the availability of Cl- to complex with the REE. These simulations highlight how fluid-rock reaction and temperature affect the mobility of REE in hydrothermal ore-forming systems.« less
  2. Mobility of heavy rare earth elements in magmatic-hydrothermal systems: Experimental determination of DyPO4 solubility in supercritical fluids

    Dysprosium (Dy) is part of the heavy rare earth elements (REE) and a critical component in the production of high-performance super magnets used in wind turbines, electric vehicles, and other green technologies. The HREE phosphate, xenotime, is commonly associated with hydrothermal systems, where the mobility, fractionation, and deposition of REE are controlled by the stability of aqueous complexes and solubility of REE minerals which depend on temperature, pressure, and fluid composition (salinity, pH, and ligand availability). Here, we conducted a series of synthetic DyPO4 solubility experiments in NaCl-HCl-bearing aqueous solutions (pH of 2 at 25 °C) from 500 to 700more » °C and 1.5 kbar using externally heated pressure vessels. DyPO4 displays a strong prograde solubility with temperature across all studied fluid salinities (0–0.5 m NaCl). The DyPO₄ solubility isotherms at 500 °C, 600 °C, and 700 °C show a complex relationship with salinity where DyPO₄ solubility is highest (39.2–1552 ppm at 500–700 °C) in 0 m NaCl solutions, decreases strongly (21–331 ppm at 500–700 °C) in the 0.06 m NaCl solutions and remains relatively constant in the 0.25 m (42.8–248 ppm) and 0.5 m NaCl (40.2–124 ppm) solutions. Thermodynamic modeling suggests that pH increases as a function of temperature and salinity, and controls solubility due to the stability of chloride complexes (i.e., DyCl+2 and DyCl2+) at 500–600 °C, transitioning to hydroxyl complexes (i.e., Dy(OH)30) dominating at 700 °C and relatively alkaline pH. Comparison with NdPO4 solubility data indicates that the light REE in monazite is significantly more soluble than the heavy REE in xenotime in saline fluids at high temperature (500–700 °C), implying efficient light/heavy REE fractionation in supercritical fluids. The lower solubility of DyPO4 relative to NdPO4 suggests that at high temperatures, acidic (pH 2–4), low-salinity (∼5 wt% NaCl) fluids will favor the precipitation of xenotime over monazite as it will cool from 700 °C to below 500 °C. These observations align with paragenetic mineral assemblages in NYF pegmatites (e.g., Baveno, Italy), where xenotime commonly immobilizes heavy REE during the high-temperature hydrothermal stages.« less
  3. An experimental study of synthetic Hydroxybastnäsite-(La) solubility and speciation in carbonate bearing aqueous solutions at 175–250 °C

    The transport and enrichment of rare earth element (REE) ore bodies are dependent on the stability of aqueous metal ligand complexes and the solubility of REE bearing minerals. REE ores are commonly associated with igneous systems having aqueous fluids with high carbonate concentrations and REE solubilities have been shown to be dependent on temperature and associate anion aqueous ligands present in solution. Furthermore, this work presents solubility experiments of hydroxybastnäsite-(La) at elevated temperatures in aqueous solutions of varying carbonate concentrations. At lower temperatures, hydroxybastnäsite-(La) solubility is controlled by neutral mono-carbonate LaCO3OH° but at higher temperatures and activities of carbonate species,more » charged di-carbonate La(CO3)2- increases and predominates. This divergence, and the difference in solubility products of other hydroxybastnäsite-(REE) phases, provides a potential mechanism for REE fractionation in carbonate dominated aqueous solutions. To illustrate one such mechanism the solubility data of hydroxybastnäsite-(La) is compared with previously reported data of hydroxybastnäsite-(Nd) at elevated temperatures.« less
  4. Quantification of the REE3+ aqua ions and chloride species in aqueous fluids by in situ Raman spectroscopy using perturbations of the water band

    Acidic NaCl-rich aqueous fluids play a crucial role in forming hydrothermal rare earth elements (REE) mineral deposits. Aqueous REE mobility is mostly controlled by the stabilities of REE3+ and REE chloride species. Our current knowledge of REE speciation is based on solubility data, thermodynamic models and in situ spectroscopic measurements, sometimes coupled with molecular simulations. Here, in this study, we investigate Nd and Yb speciation in pH2 Cl-bearing solutions at 25 °C and 0.1 MPa with variable Cl/REE ratios using Raman Spectroscopy in solutions with 0.1 to 0.6 mol/kg NdCl3 or YbCl3 and 0.2 to 3.2 mol/kg NaCl. Due tomore » the challenges in resolving the REE-Cl band, we developed a new method using the water vibrational mode and multivariate curve resolution (MCR) analysis. The Raman spectra for the vibrational band of water (2700 to 3900 cm–1) were collected at 25 °C and fitted by three Gaussian sub-peaks, then quantified using MCR analysis to de-convolute the water band into bulk H2O and the perturbations caused by of Cl, REE3+, and REE chloride species. REE speciation based on the perturbations of the water band indicates that REE3+ aqua ions dominate acidic solutions at 25 °C, but up to ~20 mol% YbCl2+ forms at high YbCl3 concentrations. The new method is promising for quantifying in situ speciation of the REE3+ aqua ions and REE chloride species in aqueous fluids while providing information on the hydration of ions. This method improves our molecular level understanding of REE aqueous species stability and their role in REE mobilization during fluid-rock interaction.« less
  5. In situ Raman investigation of Dy complexation in Cl-bearing aqueous solutions at 20–300 °C

    Raman spectroscopy provides a versatile tool for in situ characterization of aqueous rare earth elements (REE) speciation at the molecular level. Complexation of REE with ligands such as Cl and OH is of particular interest for understanding the mobility of REE in NaCl-bearing hydrothermal fluids responsible for enriching REE to economic levels in nature. Raman spectroscopic studies of REE speciation in Cl-bearing aqueous fluids are primarily conducted at ambient temperature, whereas natural systems indicate temperatures of >100–600 °C. In this study, the speciation of Dy in acidic chloride-bearing hydrothermal solutions was investigated using confocal Raman spectroscopy with a new capillarymore » Raman heating stage at 20–300 °C. Background solutions (pure water, NaCl-solutions) and solutions with 0.14–1.8 mol kg–1 dissolved DyCl3 were sealed in quartz capillary cells. Comparison of the spectra for Dy chloride solutions with those for background solutions and the spectra for reference Dy-bearing solids was used to identify Raman bands specific to Dy–O and Dy–Cl bonds. The Raman band for the Dy–O stretching mode of hydrated Dy3+ aqua ions was measured at 365–384 cm–1 and a Raman band for the Dy–Cl stretching modes of Dy chloride complexes was measured near 240 cm–1. The Dy–O band decreases systematically with temperature, whereas the Dy–Cl band systematically increases, indicating a systematic increase in the stability of Dy chloride complexes with temperature. Here, this study provides the framework for expanding the use of in situ Raman spectroscopy to investigate the speciation of REE in aqueous solutions to hydrothermal conditions.« less
  6. NdPO4 solubility and aqueous Neodymium speciation in supercritical fluids: An experimental study at 500–700 °C and 1.7 kbar

    A key aspect in the formation of rare earth elements (REE) deposits is the role of REE transport as aqueous REE complexes in supercritical hydrothermal solutions, where the nature of the aqueous complex is controlled by solution composition, temperature and pressure. Despite chloride being considered as one of the most abundant transporting ligands in magmatic-hydrothermal fluids, experimental investigations on the stability of aqueous REE chloride complexes are scarce above 300 °C. In this study, synthetic NdPO4 crystals were reacted with non-saline and saline (0, 0.05 and 0.5 mNaCl), acidic (0.01 mHCl) aqueous solutions in a series of solubility experiments conductedmore » at 500–700 °C and 1.7 kbar, where the solubilities were determined using a stable Nd isotope (145Nd isotope spike) dilution technique. NdPO4 solubility ranges between 28 ppm and 10,858 ppm, where solubility increases with both temperature and salinity. At 500 °C, log mNdPO4 increases from –3.93 to –1.60 and there is a strong correlation between NdPO4 solubility and NaCl concentrations (slope of 1.2 ± 0.3), indicating stabilization of the Nd chloride aqueous complexes with a stoichiometry corresponding to NdCl2+. At 600 °C, this correlation is weaker (slope of 0.4, log mNdPO4 increases from –2.63 to –1.88) indicating the stabilization of both Nd chloride and hydroxyl species controlling solubility. At 700 °C, NdPO4 solubility is largely independent of NaCl concentration indicating that solubility is controlled by Nd hydroxyl complexes, where stoichiometry suggests the neutral Nd(OH)30 species is dominant. The solubility product (Ksp) of NdPO4 is derived from experimental data with the relation: log Ksp = -41.81 – 0.057T – 20987/T, with T temperature in Kelvin. Comparison of the measured Nd phosphate solubility to thermodynamic predictions using the available Helgeson-Kirkham-Flowers equation of state parameters for aqueous Nd complexes indicate that predictions are up to three orders of magnitude lower compared to experimental observations. This discrepancy is most pronounced in saline solutions, suggesting that thermodynamic properties of the REE chloride species in supercritical fluids require revision. Numerical simulations of fluid-rock interaction between acidic, saline fluids and a Strange Lake felsic mineral assemblage demonstrates that NdPO4 solubility predictions from models are four to six orders of magnitude lower than those calculated based on empirical fits from experiments, which suggests that acidic, saline fluids may play an important role in mobilizing large amounts of light REE from 450 to 700 °C.« less
  7. Raman spectroscopic study of anhydrous and hydrous REE phosphates, oxides, and hydroxides

    Rare earth elements (REE) include the lanthanides (La–Lu), Y, and Sc which are critical elements for the green energy transition. The REE show a decrease in ionic radii with increased atomic numbers, which results in a so-called lanthanide contraction systematically affecting crystal structures and mineral properties. Here we present a compilation of reference Raman spectra of ten REE sesquioxides (A-, B- and C-type), five REE hydroxides, eight xenotime-structured REE phosphate endmembers and two solid solutions, seven monazite-structured REE phosphate endmembers and two solid solutions and seven rhabdophane endmembers with up to five Ce1–xLREEx rhabdophane solid solutions (LREE = La–Gd). Ramanmore » mode assignment is based on a detailed literature review summarizing existing analytical work and theoretical calculations and systematic trends observed in this study by analyzing different REE-bearing solids. Here, the wavenumbers of the main REE-O Raman band systematically increase with decreasing ionic radii forming discrete linear trends within isostructural mineral groups, that can be used to estimate the REE-O mode in other solids with known REE-O coordination numbers. Photoluminescence using 266 nm, 532 nm and 633 nm excitation laser wavelengths for REE-bearing oxides, hydroxides, anhydrous and hydrous phosphates is also presented providing a new framework for identifying REE-phases in phosphate-bearing natural mineral deposits.« less

Search for:
All Records
Creator / Author
"Hurtig, Nicole"

Refine by:
Article Type
Availability
Journal
Creator / Author
Publication Date
Research Organization